Contrast and resolution of different telescopes

The following telescopes designs have been simulated to derive data about their relative levels of contrast and resolution. The method is described in a previous post, Calculating diffraction patterns. However, in summary, the closer the resolution figure is to zero, the better, and the closer contrast figures are to one, the better!

  • Resolution is calculated as the radius of the first minimum of the diffraction pattern.
  • Contrast is calculated as the ratio of light in a 1 arcsec radius of the focal point to the light in a larger circle (figures are given for 10 and 30 arcsecs). A perfect telescope would have a contrast of 1.0 in this scheme.

UPDATED (2015-05-05): The sampling has been greatly increased (9x) as has the resolution of the spot diagrams (2x), in comparison to the first set of data originally posted. In addition a number of bugs in the calculation methods have been resolved. I am reposting the data in batches, starting primarily with refractors.

Telescope Resolution (arcsec) 10 arcsec Contrast 30 arcsec Contrast
Schmidt Cassegrain
150mm
37% Obstruction
0.755 0.676 0.667
Schmidt Cassegrain
200mm
34% Obstruction
0.575 0.867 0.858
Schmidt Cassegrain
280mm
34% Obstruction
0.410 0.913 0.906
Maksutov Cassegrain
102mm
33% Obstruction
1.130 0.675 0.661
Refractor
60mm
0% Obstruction
2.140 0.563 0.549
Refractor
80mm
0% Obstruction
1.605 0.748 0.735
Refractor
100mm
0% Obstruction
1.285 0.836 0.825
Refractor
120mm
0% Obstruction
1.070 0.854 0.845
Refractor
150mm
0% Obstruction
0.855 0.858 0.850
Refractor
180mm
0% Obstruction
0.715 0.891 0.884
Refractor
200mm
0% Obstruction
0.640 0.912 0.906
Newtonian
150mm
0.5mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.800 0.761 0.751
Newtonian
150mm
1mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.800 0.759 0.746
Newtonian
150mm
2mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.795 0.752 0.734
Newtonian
150mm
0.5mm Spider
20% Obstruction
0.815 0.792 0.782
Newtonian
150mm
0.5mm Spider
30% Obstruction
0.780 0.726 0.716
Newtonian
200mm
0.5mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.600 0.881 0.872
Newtonian
300mm
0.5mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.400 0.915 0.908
Newtonian
400mm
0.5mm Spider
25% Obstruction
0.300 0.939 0.933

Comments

Popular Posts